HOA and condo

Unpaid assessments and contested fines: a path between a reminder letter and a lawsuit.

Arbitration.Inc

Every association has them: an owner who stopped paying assessments, a fine the owner says was unfair, a late fee that has been disputed for a year. Board members want them settled, and neighbors want them settled fairly. A lawsuit against a fellow owner over a few hundred dollars rarely feels like either.

Why small association disputes linger

An association has a few tools for an unpaid balance or a contested fine: reminder letters, a hearing before the board, a payment plan, and, at the far end, legal action. The last step is expensive, slow, and hard on a community. So small balances sit on the books, fines go unresolved, and the same disagreement comes back at every annual meeting.

Contested fines carry a second problem. When the board that issued a fine also decides the appeal, the owner may never accept the outcome as fair, however careful the board was.

A neutral decision, on the documents

Arbitration puts the question in front of a decision maker that is not the board, not the management company, and not the owner. Both sides submit their documents: the governing documents and rules, the account ledger, the violation notices, photos, and any correspondence. Our AI decides on the record both sides submit, under our published Rules. Either side can add Human Review.

For the board, that means a decision it did not have to make itself. For the owner, it means someone independent looked at their side.

What it needs: an agreement to arbitrate

Arbitration rests on a written agreement. For associations, that may live in the governing documents, such as the CC&Rs or bylaws, or the association and an owner can agree to arbitrate a specific dispute. Rules for associations differ from state to state, so the association's attorney should confirm what your documents allow.

What filing looks like on Arbitration.Inc

On Arbitration.Inc, the association or its manager files the claim online with the governing documents, the ledger, and the notices attached. The owner is served a notice of arbitration and can respond with their own position and evidence. A party can ask a court to confirm the award, which turns it into a court judgment, where the parties agreed to arbitrate, in writing or otherwise.

An owner can file too, for example to contest a fine. Arbitration.Inc is the forum, not either side's agent.

Before you file

Keep each account's ledger current and every violation notice dated and on file. Make sure the rule behind each fine is written down where owners can find it. Clear records shorten any dispute, whichever way it is decided.

Arbitration.Inc does not give legal advice. For questions about your governing documents or your state's rules, speak with the association's attorney.

New to the terms? Read what arbitration is or the plain-English glossary. See how a case runs for HOA & Condo.

Related

Before the lien: how HOA balance disputes get settled

When an owner and an association disagree about the amount itself, the usual steps rarely end the argument. Here is the problem, and one way to solve it.

A past due invoice that is too small to sue over. Now what?

A client stopped paying an invoice of a few hundred or a few thousand dollars, and a lawsuit costs more than it is worth. How arbitration gives it a decision.

How a case works

From filing to a written award, step by step.

The Rules

The published Rules every case is decided under.

See it on your use case.

Tell us what kind of disputes you carry and we will show you how a case runs, typically within a day or two.